Hearing stream 3

Hearing Stream 3 was held on 3-10 December 2021. It covered:

  • Strategic Directions related to Resilience, Efficiency & Energy and Historic and Cultural Heritage
  • Contaminated land
  • Hazardous substances
  • Natural Hazards
  • Coastal Environment
  • Historic Heritage including extent of land the subject of overlay
  • Sites and Areas of Significance to Maori
  • Notable Trees including the extent of land the subject of overlay

You can watch the hearings via our livestream on YouTube.

Key dates

Key dates for Hearing Stream 3 as per the Hearing Schedule are:

  • 5 November - s42A Officers' reports published
  • 19 November - Submitters wishing to submit expert evidence must do so before 1pm on this date
  • 3,6-8,10 December - Dates set aside for Hearing Stream 3
  • 22 December - Council's reply will be due.

Key documents

Notice of Hearing for Hearing Stream 3

Hearing Stream 3 Schedule - Updated 7 December 2021

List of Submitters for Hearing Stream 3.pdf

Expert conferencing

Joint Witness Statement for Notable Trees

Joint Witness Statement for Natural Hazards - Fault Rapture Zone

Joint Witness Statement for Historic Heritage

S42a reports

Section 42A Report - Part B Coastal Environment
Section 42A Report - Part B Contaminated Land
Section 42A Report - Part B Hazardous Substances
Section 42A Report - Part B Natural Hazards
Section 42A Report - Part B Sites And Areas Of Significance To Māori
Section 42A Report - Part B Strategic Directions For Historic & Cultural Heritage And Resilience, Efficiency And Energy
Section 42A Report Part B - Historic Heritage
Section 42A Report Part B - Notable Trees

Note:

Two minor corrections were made to Section 42A Reports on 8 November 2021 as follows:

  • Section 42A Report - Part B Coastal Environment: further submission point FS40.16 was incorrectly attributed in Appendix B to submission point 225.200, this has been amended to the correct submission point 11.55.
  • Section 42A Report - Part B Natural Hazards: a cross-referencing error was corrected on pages 2 and 3 of Appendix B

Council evidence

Addendum To Council Statement Of Evidence By Rhys Girvan Of Boffa Miskell – Landscape Planner (6 December 2021)
Council Statement Of Evidence By Bronwen Gibberd Of 4D Environmental - Coastal Scientist
Council Statement Of Evidence By David Spencer Of Tend Trees - Arborist
Council Statement Of Evidence By Dr Nicola Litchfield Of Gns Science - Earthquake Geologist
Council Statement Of Evidence By Dr William Power Of Gns Science - Geophysicist
Council Statement Of Evidence By Gregory Vossler, Planner And Heritage Adviser, And Ian Bowman, Architect And Conservator
Council Statement Of Evidence By Leon Saxon Of Arborlab Consultancy Services Ltd - Arborist
Council Statement Of Evidence By Nadia Nitsche Of Wellington Water - Modelling Manager
Council Statement Of Evidence By Rhys Girvan Of Boffa Miskell – Landscape Planner

Council supplementary evidence

Statement Of Supplementary Arboricultural Evidence -Of Leon Saxon On Behalf Of Porirua City Council
Statement Of Supplementary Arboricultural Evidence Of David Spencer On Behalf Of Porirua City Council
Statement Of Supplementary Planning Evidence - Torrey Mcdonnell - Hearing Stream 3
Statement Of Supplementary Planning Evidence By Caroline Rachlin - Hearing Stream 3
Statement Of Supplementary Planning Evidence By Michael Rachlin - Contaminated Land

Council response

Response to Panel regarding historic heritage matters - Caroline Rachlin (9 December 2021)

Submitter presentations

Submitter Presentation - David Sullivan For Kenepuru Partnerships Ltd {59 And Fs29]
Submitter Presentation - Paul Botha [118]
Submitter Speaking Notes - Karen Williams For Kāinga Ora [81 And Fs65]
Submitter Speaking Notes - Robyn Smith [168]
Submitter Speaking Notes - Te Rūnanga O Toa Rangatira [Fs70]
Submitter Speaking Notes And Map - Graeme Ebbett For The Titahi Bay Residents Association [90]

Submitter statements

Submitter Statement - Grant And Jane Abdee [238]
Submitter Statement - Heriot Drive Ltd [156] And Raiha Properties Ltd [157]
Submitter Statement - Robyn Smith [168]
Submitter Statement - Titahi Bay Residents Association [95]
Submitter Statement 2 - Heriot Drive Ltd [156] And Raiha Properties Ltd [157]
Submitter Supplementary Statement - Heritage Nz [65 And Fs14]
Submitter Tabled Document In Relation To Verbal Statement - Robyn Smith [168]
Submitter Tabled Letter - Thomas And Claire Clark [153]
Submitter Tabled Statement - Waka Kotahi [82 And Fs36]
Submitter Tabled Statement - Fire And Emergency New Zealand [119 And Fs54]
Submitter Tabled Statement - Ministry Of Education [134]
Submitter Tabled Statement - Oil Companies [123] - Attachment
Submitter Tabled Statement - Oil Companies [123]
Submitter Tabled Statement - Paremata Business Park Ltd [69]
Submitter Tabled Statement - Pikarere Farm Ltd [136]
Submitter Tabled Statement - Transpower New Zealand [60 And Fs04]

Submitter evidence

Submitter Evidence - Alison Dangerfield For Heritage Nz [65 And Fs14]
Submitter Evidence - Brendan Scott Liggett For Kāinga Ora [81 And Fs65]
Submitter Evidence - David Sullivan For Kenepuru Limited Partnership [59 And Fs20]
Submitter Evidence - Dean Raymond For Heritage Nz [65 And Fs14]
Submitter Evidence - Graeme La Cock For The Director-General Of Conservation [126 And Fs39]
Submitter Evidence - Graeme Silver For The Director-General Of Conservation [126 And Fs39]
Submitter Evidence - Iain Dawe For Gwrc [173 And Fs40]
Submitter Evidence - Jez Partridge - Appendix 1 (Tree And Root Protection Methods Bs58371 1991) [103]
Submitter Evidence - Jez Partridge - Appendix 2 (Example Of Councils Using Root Protection Method Taken From Bs5837 1991) [103]
Submitter Evidence - Jez Partridge - Appendix 3 (Norfolk Island Pine, 26 Tireti Road) [103]
Submitter Evidence - Jez Partridge - Appendix 4 (Hydrovac Versus Airvac) [103]
Submitter Evidence - Jez Partridge - Appendix 5 - (Dripline Half Height Versus 12 X Stem Diameter For Rpa Definition) [103]-
Submitter Evidence - Jez Partridge [103]
Submitter Evidence - Karen Tracy Williams For Kāinga Ora [81 And Fs65]
Submitter Evidence - Rodney David Witte For Heriot Drive Ltd And Raiha Properties Ltd [156 And 157]

Submitter legal submissions

Submitter Legal Submissions - Katherine Anton And Rosemary Broad For The Director-General Of Conservation [126 And Fs39]
Submitter Legal Submissions - Nick Whittington For Kainga Ora [81 And Fs65]

Council reply

Addendum To Council Reply - Caroline Rachlin - Historic Heritage (11 Feb 22)
Addendum To Reply - Gregory Vossler And Ian Bowman - Historic Heritage (11 Feb 22) (4)
Council Reply - Caroline Rachlin - Historic Heritage
Council Reply - Caroline Rachlin - Notable Trees
Council Reply - Caroline Rachlin - Sites And Areas Of Significance To Māori
Council Reply - Gina Sweetman - Strategic Directions Addressed Hearing Stream 3
Council Reply - Michael Rachlin - Hazardous Substances And Contaminated Land
Council Reply - Torrey Mcdonnell - Natural Hazards And Coastal Environment
Reply - Gregory Vossler And Ian Bowman - Historic Heritage
Reply - Leon Saxon - Notable Trees